Menhaden

Long Island


This stylish newcomer is Greenport's most upscale option but it never feels like a stuffy top-end hotel. The 16 rooms feature large bathrooms with raised button flooring and are decked out in soothing and subdued earth tones (blues, beiges, greys) with driftwood accents. Art features heavily, from Scott Farrell's common area photographs of magnified boat hulls to hand-painted restaurant walls.

It's pricey, but perks loom large: a rooftop patio with firepits, free bikes, rides around town in an electric Moke, and access to galleys on each floor stocked with Häagen-Dazs ice-cream bars, San Pellegrino, greek yogurt and artisanal juices and muffins (breakfast is weekends only).


Lonely Planet's must-see attractions

Nearby Long Island attractions

1. Kontokosta Winery

1.2 MILES

One of the newer kids on the North Fork wine block, yet already producing award-winning vintages. You'll be as wowed by the scenery – it's the only local…

2. Crescent Beach

1.93 MILES

A half-mile of sun-kissed sands with numerous picnic tables, lifeguards on duty and at least two hotels with restaurant and bar services. It's known as…

3. Wades Beach

3.93 MILES

A lovely stretch of Shelter Island sand that is popular with families. There are a few picnic tables as well as a roped-off swimming area that's calm and…

4. Horton Point Lighthouse

4.48 MILES

Perhaps a poorer sister to the famous Montauk lighthouse, Horton Point was also commissioned by President Washington, but finally built 60 years later by…

5. Orient Beach State Park

5.33 MILES

A sandy slip of land at the end of the North Fork, where you can swim in the calm ocean water (July and August only; 10:30am to 6pm) or rent kayaks to…

6. Mashomack Nature Preserve

5.34 MILES

The 2000 acres of this Shelter Island reserve, shot through with creeks and marshes, are great for kayaking, birding and hiking (no cycling allowed). Take…

7. Lenz Winery

7.02 MILES

Established in 1978, this is one of the oldest North Fork wineries, and still one of the more eclectic, focusing on European-style wines. The sparkling…

8. Pindar Vineyards

7.22 MILES

Iconic Pindar retains the original flavor of North Fork wine, for it was here that the island's boutique industry began back in the 1970s. What was once a…