Company of the Cauldron

Top choice in Nantucket


A splendid choice for a romantic dinner, this intimate restaurant has attentive service and top-rated food. It offers only reserved seating times and four-course prix-fixe dinners, with the likes of rosemary-skewered shrimp followed by beef tournedos. As the chef concentrates his magic on just one menu each evening, it's done to perfection. Book early for Lobster Monday.

Winter hours can fluctuate, especially around Thanksgiving and Christmas when you may find the restaurant open extra days.


Lonely Planet's must-see attractions

Nearby Nantucket attractions

1. Nantucket Atheneum

0.04 MILES

More than just the public library, this stately Greek Revival edifice is a sight in itself. The 2nd-floor Great Hall has hosted such notables as Ralph…

2. Nantucket Whaling Museum

0.1 MILES

One of the island's highlights, this evocative museum occupies an 1847 spermaceti (whale oil) candle factory and the excellent exhibits relive Nantucket's…

3. First Congregational Church

0.17 MILES

Everyone comes to this church, which traces its roots to the early 1700s, for the eagle-eye view from the top of the steeple. It's well worth the 94-step…

4. Hadwen House

0.22 MILES

A walk through the Nantucket Historical Association’s Hadwen House, a Greek Revival home built in 1845 by a whaling merchant, provides testimony to just…

5. Children's Beach

0.25 MILES

Right in town, Children's Beach is heaven for young kids, with gentle water, a fun playground and picnic facilities. It's along S Beach St at the north…

6. Nantucket Lightship Basket Museum

0.42 MILES

What the lighthouse is to the New England coast, the lightship was to the sea – essentially a floating lighthouse to warn of dangerous shoals or sandbars…

7. Old Gaol

0.43 MILES

To see where drunken sailors used to spend the night, visit the Old Gaol, the c 1806 jail that served Nantucket for 125 years. It was constructed using…

8. Jethro Coffin House

0.44 MILES

Built in 1686, the Jethro Coffin House is the town’s oldest building still on its original foundation. It’s in a traditional ‘salt box’ style, with south…