One of the most talked-about restaurants in the Keys, Square Grouper hits all the right notes with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, innovative recipes and great service, all dished up in one elegant but unpretentious dining room. Local fish-of-the-day tacos, seared sesame-encrusted tuna loin and a rich seafood stew are among the highlights, though it's worth investigating daily specials.
Reserve ahead. And don't forget to have a pre- or post-dinner drink in the upstairs lounge My New Joint.