Right at the top of the hill overlooking Spring Bay, this intimate hotel feels like your private retreat on a secluded island. The 10 rooms are elegant with hardwood floors, massive bathrooms and classic furnishings, and the only sound you'll hear is birdsong from the surrounding bush. A number of terraces, including one with a spa bath, offer fantastic sea views.
It's a bit of a hike to town or the water, but management offers a free shuttle and will even load the complimentary kayaks onto the truck if you fancy paddling from bay to bay.