A rough-and-ready crowd fuels up on Caribs and seafood at this castaway bar on picturesque Cockleshell Beach. Sleep it off on an umbrella-shaded beach chair (US$10 per day), get a massage or snorkel with tropical fish hiding out in the protected reef. Best night: Fridays for the lobster-fest (reservations recommended).
The place used to be home to Wilbur, a legendary pot-bellied pig that died in 2012. Look for the memorial under the trees.