Club Comanche Hotel St Croix

This character-rich property, set in a 250-year-old Danish mansion, gives off a boutique-hotel vibe. The 27 rooms have West Indian antique decor, comfy beds, flat-screen satellite TVs and decent wi-fi, though the walls are rather thin. It’s in the heart of Christiansted’s entertainment district, right by the boardwalk, which means the area can be a tad noisy.