The central Victorian Inn has been reborn as the Christopher, and the makeover has been quite something: bright, bold and boutique in the best possible way. Edgartown is just outside your doorstep, but inside it's about high-tech gadgets, stylish nooks and a cool outdoor courtyard with a fire pit. Fifteen rooms are spread over three floors (note: no elevator).
It has an equally stylish sister hotel, the Sydney, just down the road.