This simple place has 15 clean and comfortable rooms, each with full beds and big windows. The warm welcome from hosts Alberto and Francia and the outstanding cooking (including homemade bread, fish dishes and veggie options; meals M$100) really make this place stand out. Area tours are also offered (from M$150 per person; minimum two people). English spoken.
They'll pick you up at Bahuichivo train station if you have reserved a room.