Mango Café

Owned by Andrea, an Italian who's lived in Utila since the 1990s, this place specializes in authentic thin-crust pizza from a purpose-built brick oven. The menu runs from egg sandwiches and burritos to seared tuna, coconut shrimp and wine-poached snapper fillet; there's always a daily special too. If you eat here you're welcome to use the hotel pool and sunbeds.