It's hard to go wrong at this quaint little spot, which has seven airy rooms with wrought-iron beds, sea views and access to the beach. It's within walking distance of the ferry dock, and has one of the island's most tasteful restaurants (mains $20 to $25) with big windows, daily fresh menus and sumptuous desserts.
Handily, the owner also runs the local kayaking company and guests get a discount.