At this simple, small roadside restaurant south of town, Jamaican BBQ king Robin prepares the best jerk chicken and fish this side of Kingston. Dishes are spicy but with subtle flavors, and his sauces are also to die for. If you catch your own fish, Robin will prepare it for you any way you like and will only charge for sides.
He also prepares vegetarian dishes. It's a fair hike south of town, opposite the Royal Palms Resort, but well worth the trip.